Categories: CommentResponse

Response to Comment on “Individual heterozygosity predicts translocation success in threatened desert tortoises”


Hansson et al. argue that our main finding could provide an overly simplistic metric for maximizing genetic rescue. They agree that translocating the most genetically diverse individuals led to a large increase in translocated tortoise survival, but recommend instead moving individuals that have low genetic load and the greatest representation of metapopulation diversity. Their recommendation is based on specific model assumptions and fitness effects that are often unknown and are not generalizable to many endangered species applications.

Scott et al. (1) showed that individual heterozygosity, but not genetic clade of origin or geographic distance, was correlated with post-translocation survival in Mojave desert tortoises. With this main finding, we argued that individual heterozygosity is an important tool that conservation biologists could use when considering which individuals to translocate. Hansson et al. (2) argue that this recommendation could be misguided because it ignores the potential increase in genetic load that could follow post-translocation breeding. They argue that translocating less-heterozygous individuals that have been purged of deleterious variation would be a safer approach, and they provide simulation data to support their argument. Hansson et al.’s critique may be reasonable for certain specific instances of genetic rescue, but they are probably not generalizable, nor do they negate our results. Here, we argue that our finding is still important when planning translocations, and we reiterate the conclusion from Scott et al. that many ecological and genetic factors should be considered in translocation programs. We stand by our primary conclusion: For translocations to be successful, individuals must survive, and more heterozygous individuals have higher survival. Additional population benefits in later generations are important, but survival of the translocated individuals must happen first, and for most species, survival after translocation is the most deadly part of the translocation process (36).

Hansson et al. imply that we recommend individual heterozygosity as the only, or primary, consideration when translocating individuals, which we do not. They then draw upon the sometimes controversial but long-standing modeling tradition that uses simulations and population genetic theory to determine the optimal source population(s) to be used to facilitate genetic rescue (7). Under a specific set of population-differentiation conditions, Hansson et al. show that translocating the 20% of individuals with the highest genetic diversity may have two main effects: (i) If there is a lot of genetic structure in a species, then one may end up translocating only a subset of the total species-level genetic diversity, because those 20% may come exclusively from one or a few demes; and (ii) choosing that set of individuals may increase genetic load in subsequent generations relative to other translocatee selection scenarios. These results may be true in an idealized situation. However, they do not reflect the reality or goals of tortoise translocations that we investigated. Hansson et al. model a specific partitioning of genetic variation within and among demes, and they suggest that by selecting only the most diverse individuals overall, some demes will not have heterozygous enough individuals to be translocated, thereby resulting in lost among-deme diversity. If that among-deme diversity is tied to fitness, either of translocated individuals or of their offspring, then an important component of genetic variation is potentially lost. All of this may be true, or it may not, and it almost certainly varies across case studies. In the Mojave desert tortoise, there are two major genetic groups (north and south) and a strong component of isolation by distance within each. We show that there is no difference in the geographic distance translocated or genetic population of origin between those individuals that lived or perished after translocation [figures 2 and 3 of (1)]. There is some uncertainty (about 36 km on average) in the site of origin of translocated tortoises, but this should not be biased by tortoise status; therefore, there is no reason that Hansson et al.’s suggestion that there is “substantial noise” in our inferred tortoise origins would change our main finding. Only individual heterozygosity made a difference.

As we originally pointed out (1), there are many potential goals motivating translocations, including the repatriation of displaced individuals, population supplementation/reestablishment, facilitating the flow of adaptive variation, and genetic rescue. The potential for increased genetic load may or may not rank highly given these goals and situations. Given the near-impossibility of accurately estimating the fitness consequences of individual substitutions across the genome, we are doubtful that empirical studies will be able to simultaneously model the joint positive effects of heterozygosity on survival and the negative effects of different allelic combinations post-breeding in most conservation-relevant systems. Although models such as genomic evolutionary rate profiling (GERP) (8) may make it possible to estimate potential genomic load based on genomic signatures, these models are at best an approximation of load. Additionally, there appears to be little correlation between neutral genome-wide genetic variation and inbreeding depression, genetic load, or adaptive potential (9); thus, one really needs to understand individual loci for the load argument to be effective. Therefore, in those situations where minimiz

Read More

News Bot

Published by
News Bot

Recent Posts

Kuda, the African challenger bank, raises $55M at a $500M valuation

Kuda Bank, the London-based, Nigerian-operating startup that is taking on incumbents in the country with…

12 mins ago

Indian online insurer PolicyBazaar files for IPO, seeks to raise over $800 million

Indian online insurance aggregator PolicyBazaar has filed for an initial public offering in which it…

12 mins ago

Indian edtech Unacademy valued at $3.44 billion in $440 million fundraise

Indian online learning platform Unacademy has raised $440 million in a new financing round as…

12 mins ago

Square to buy ‘buy now, pay later’ giant Afterpay in $29B deal

In a blockbuster deal that rocks the fintech world, Square announced today that it is…

12 mins ago

Unicorns are ready for a haircut

The digitization of your haircut may not have been on your 2020 bucket list, but…

12 mins ago

Super Nintendo World’s Donkey Kong zone may already be under construction

Super Nintendo World, the Super Mario-themed area of Universal Studios Japan in Osaka, finally opened…

12 mins ago